Okay, let’s get straight to it. You’re here because you, like me, are obsessed with Only Murders in the Building . The Arconia, the podcasts, the quirky characters, and the oh-so-clever mysteries what’s not to love? So, the big question buzzing around like a Mabel Mora conspiracy theory is: will there be an Only Murders in the Building season 5 ?
I initially thought this was a simple yes/no answer, but let’s be honest, with a show this popular, it’s a bit more nuanced than that. What fascinates me is the delicate dance between critical acclaim, actor availability (Selena Gomez is kinda a big deal, ya know?), and, of course, cold, hard streaming numbers. So, let’s dive deep, shall we?
The Current Status | Officially Renewed (But With a Catch)

Here’s the good news: Only Murders in the Building has officially been renewed for a fifth season! Hooray! This announcement sent ripples of excitement through the fan base. But, and this is a big ‘but’, the renewal doesn’t tell the whole story. It’s not just about if there will be a season 5, it’s about when and how it will all come together. After all, the show’s success hinges on the unique chemistry of its core cast.
Why the Delay? Decoding the Production Puzzle
So, why aren’t we already knee-deep in season 5 theories? Well, a few factors are at play. The entertainment industry is a complex beast, and scheduling conflicts are common. And, let’s face it, Steve Martin isn’t getting any younger, and his recent statements about retirement have definitely added fuel to the fire. The showrunners are likely being very strategic about mapping out the future of the series.
Here’s the thing: the show’s writing is so sharp, so witty, that it takes time to craft those intricate mysteries. And with the pressure of maintaining the show’s high standards, they aren’t going to rush into anything. It is important to note that the show’s writing is not only meant to be clever, but also to serve as a critical acclaim factor .
It is also likely that there has been an internal discussion as to how many seasons there should be of the show. As seen here , the stars may have a say in how long the show continues.
What Could Season 5 Look Like? Plot Theories and Dream Guest Stars
Okay, let’s get speculative! What could season 5 be about? The possibilities are endless. Will they stay in the Arconia? Will they venture out into the wider world of New York City? Will another residentmeet an untimely end? (Probably.)
One popular theory is that the new season could focus on the history of the Arconia itself, diving into some long-buried secrets and perhaps even a ghost or two. Or maybe they will focus on some side character. What fascinates me most is the show’s ability to seamlessly blend humor with genuine suspense, so I am excited for a continuation of that.
Here’s a bold prediction: I think we might see a significant time jump. Perhaps a few years into the future, with Mabel pursuing her art career, Oliver trying to revive his theatrical ambitions, and Charles… well, Charles will probably still be dealing with Lucy’s teenage angst. This would certainly add an interesting twist to the formula.
The Importance of the Streaming Numbers for the show’s future
While critical acclaim is fantastic, streaming numbers are the lifeblood of any show in the modern television landscape. Platforms like Hulu are driven by viewership, and if a show isn’t performing well, it won’t be renewed, regardless of how much critics love it. So, how is Only Murders in the Building doing in that regard?
The show has consistently been one of Hulu’s most popular series, attracting a broad audience and generating significant buzz on social media. This is a huge positive sign for the show’s longevity. But, and here’s another ‘but’, maintaining those numbers is crucial. The show needs to keep delivering fresh, engaging content to keep viewers hooked.
And, it’s not just about the overall viewership. It’s also about how many people are watching each episode, how long they are watching for, and how many people are coming back for more. These are the metrics that Hulu is looking at when deciding whether or not to renew a show.
Steve Martin’s Retirement: A Looming Question Mark
Let’s address the elephant in the room: Steve Martin’s hints at retirement. The iconic comedian has suggested he might be winding down his acting career, which understandably has fans worried about the future of Only Murders in the Building . It’s difficult to imagine the show without Charles-Haden Savage’s quirky charm and impeccable comedic timing.
However, don’t despair just yet! Martin has also expressed his love for the show and his dedication to seeing it through. It’s possible that he might take on a reduced role in future seasons, or perhaps even transition into a behind-the-scenes role as a writer or producer. It is crucial to note that the show’s success relies heavily on its core cast .
Ultimately, the future of the show will depend on a combination of factors, including Martin’s availability, the show’s continued success, and the creative vision of the showrunners. But, one thing is for sure: the fans are eager to see what happens next.
Final Thoughts | The Arconia’s Mystery Continues…
So, will there be an Only Murders in the Building season 5 ? Yes, but with a few asterisks. The road ahead might be a bit uncertain, but the passion of the fans, the talent of the cast and crew, and the sheer brilliance of the show’s concept should carry it through. Keep your ears open for clues, your eyes peeled for suspects, and your podcast apps ready. The mystery of the Arconia is far from over! And you can always review other shows and movies as seen here.
FAQ About Only Murders in the Building Season 5
When is the expected release date for season 5?
An official release date hasn’t been announced, but given the production timelines of previous seasons, late 2024 or early 2025 seems likely.
Will the original cast return for season 5?
We expect Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez to return, but any changes to the core cast will be revealed closer to the release date.
What will season 5 be about?
The plot is still under wraps, but expect a brand-new mystery with plenty of twists and turns set in and around the Arconia.
Where can I watch Only Murders in the Building?
You can stream all seasons of Only Murders in the Building exclusively on Hulu.
Will there be more celebrity guest stars in season 5?
Given the show’s track record, it’s highly likely that season 5 will feature some exciting new celebrity guest stars.
Is there a trailer for season 5 yet?
Not yet, but keep an eye on Hulu’s social media channels for updates and teasers as we get closer to the release date.